5/18/2023 0 Comments The immortal irishman review![]() ![]() ![]() What he doesn’t tell us is that well over 3.4 billion pounds of grain were imported. He tells us with a mounting sense of outrage that 1.5 billion pounds of grain and other foodstuffs were exported from Ireland during the famine. Egan has an effective way of dealing with this historiography: He simply ignores it. If you ally craving such a referred The Immortal. But to view the famine as an act of genocide is to fly in the face of Irish scholarly research on the subject. An American Hero as well as review them wherever you are now. The most egregious example of myth-making is Egan’s description of the famine as a “genocidal horror.” There is no doubt that it was a horror and that British relief policies were inadequate and inconsistent. In fact, as historian Donald Harman Akenson has demonstrated, they were indentured servants rather than slaves, and some dispossessed Irish Catholics actually wound up as slave-owners. Egan tells us, for example, that 50,000 Irish were deported to the West Indies as slaves on sugar plantations. There is nary a shred of nuance, and we proceed at the rate of a myth a minute. ![]() He begins by taking us on a 700-year tour of Irish history, which is reduced to a series of atrocities against a colonized people. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |